
How do you know how well apprenticeship assessment and feedback is working for your learners?
Our Assessment Effectiveness Review gives apprenticeship providers and assessment organisations an independent view of their assessment and feedback. We review live assessment and quality evidence, identifying strengths, risks and areas for improvement.
The review is for leaders responsible for assessment, quality, apprenticeships and internal quality assurance (IQA). It examines whether assessment helps learners progress and provides sound evidence of occupational proficiency.
Know what happens in practice
The review offers an independent view of established practice or a closer look at concerns such as inconsistent judgements and feedback learners struggle to use.
We agree what to review with you, based on your provision, learners, priorities and available evidence.
We sample assessment tasks, learner work, assessor decisions, feedback and learner responses. We also examine progress-review evidence, reasonable adjustments and relevant IQA activity to understand how judgements are reached and how assessment informs learning.
What it covers
- Proficiency, methods and evidence: clarity about intended proficiency, valid methods and sufficient evidence to support the conclusions drawn.
- Judgement and consistency: defensible decisions across assessors and learner groups, supported by standardisation and IQA.
- Feedback, learner response and progress: useful feedback, how apprentices act on it, and how evidence informs teaching, training, workplace activity or support.
- Inclusion, accessibility and authenticity: opportunities to demonstrate proficiency and reasonable adjustments that preserve validity. Where relevant, the review can examine authenticity where AI may have been used.
Your report and prioritised improvement plan
You receive a concise strengths-and-risks report, a prioritised improvement plan and recommended next steps, based on the evidence sampled.
The findings help you decide what to change in assessment and feedback to support apprentice progress and occupational proficiency. The review does not guarantee achievement, regulatory or inspection outcomes.
Additional support
Depending on where you need support, an Assessment Effectiveness Review can be combined with the following options:
- Mesma™ software: For assessment readiness diagnostics and monitoring implementation.
- Ready for Changing Apprenticeship Assessment Review: take stock of your readiness, identify gaps and decide where to focus.
- Assessment Practice Accelerator: turn standards, specifications or assessment outcomes into reliable assessment practice.
- Assessment Assurance Partner: sustained independent challenge and assurance.
- Bespoke staff workshops and other professional development.
You can commission the effectiveness review directly. Software and further support are optional and agreed separately; ongoing assurance and outsourced IQA are not included in the review.
Our approach and methodology
Our work follows the CLEAR Consultancy Framework aligned with ISO and our Assessment Design Principles bring evidence-led rigour to our assessment work. Together, they give you a robust approach from design through to delivery and assurance.
Extremely informative, with some excellent ideas on how we could use AI to help us improve assessment and assessment planning. Also extremely informative as to how AI use can be subverted and what to look out for.
Really informative, I liked how the focus was on different usage of AI, red hat black hat, it gave me some clear actions to think about, some that were also new to me. The PP presentation was informative, was please to hear that this will be also sent out too!
Very good, well-balanced, clear information. Pitched at a good level and prompting lots of thoughts.
– Apprenticeship assessment delegates
Let’s discuss your priorities
Tell us about your provision, the framework you use and your assessment priorities. We’ll discuss the evidence available and help you decide whether an Assessment Effectiveness Review or other support is right for you. The initial conversation is free and without obligation.
Talk to us free of charge and with no obligation.
